DVD365.net
Churchill : The Hollywood Years (2004) artwork

Churchill : The Hollywood Years (2004)

5th April 2005

For fifty years the world believed that Winston Churchill was an elderly statesman who led the British people to victory, and that he was English. Trouble is, they were wrong.
Neve Campbell, Christian Slater, Mark Caven, Jon Culshaw, Harry Enfield, Rik Mayall, Bob Mortimer, Jessica Oyelowo, Leslie Phillips, Vic Reeves, Miranda Richardson, Antony Sher
Comedy, War/Western
2
1 Hour 20 Minutes

The year is 1939 and the war is not going to well for Britain. Standing alone against the Nazi onslaught and making a tidy retreat from the beaches of Dunkirk, it's looking like Adolf Hitler is going to be walking down Marble Arch in no time. That's until Winston Churchill, an all American machine-gunning action hero reminiscent of Bruce Willis, turns up at the foreign office with the newly captured Enigma machine which allow the British to decode the German messages and bring the war to a swift end. But what's with the name I hear you ask? Is it just a coincidence or is the famous image of the portly Englishman with a fat cigar, believed for decades by the public to be Winston Churchill, in fact an actor pretending to be our war time hero?

In an even more bizarre twist, it is also believed that the same Winston Churchill fell in love with the young English princess, Elizabeth. However, he was not the only historical figure to fall for the princess, with the visiting dictator Adolf Hitler demanding to be married to the young future monarch, despite the presence of his feisty lover Eva Braun. Naturally, with all this newly discovered information just waiting to reach the public domain, it's hardly surprising that the establishment has kept it a secret for years. And now thanks to one Lieutenant Ed Baker who is searching for his father, it may just be about to surface.

The picture is surprisingly bright and colourful with a richness that defies its probable low production budget. The textures are rich and detailed whilst the exotic sets and costumes look particularly impressive. Still, the usual problems with too much contrast can occasionally be a problem, especially during some of the dimly lit interior scenes, but on the whole it's not much of an issue. Also, I think that the subtle attempts to reproduce the colour levels from war films of old have also caused a few of the problems. Finally, for such a recent release the transfer is clean and free from signs of dust scratches or other picture imperfections.

The Dolby Digital 448 Kbps soundtrack is surprisingly effective with some excellent surround effects, thumping LFE's from the bass heavy soundtrack (especially during the Siegfried Line Rap) and some clear and precise dialogue in the centre channel. But it's the surround channels where Churchill : The Hollywood Years truly shines. With plenty of action effects, the musical score and an abundance of ambient effects making their way to the rear channels, it's one of the most dynamic soundtracks you'll hear in a long time. And what makes it all the surprising is that's it's a British film and it's been made on a tight budget too. Full marks to the director and producer.

The main menu is pleasantly animated with cut scenes from the film as well as being scored. There's also some nice transition effects between the menus, with no menu left static and silent, whilst the Special Features menus are particularly impressive. Even more surprisingly, the menu system is scored in full blown Dolby Digital and once the film starts you get a nice flyby from a couple of aircraft (American, naturally). Extras wise, for what is a fairly low key film, there's a good selection on offer which manages to give the package a much needed boost.

The main extra on the disc is the Commentary with Christian Slater and Director Peter Richardson. And to be fair to Christian Slater he's thrown some weighty enthusiasm behind this project and gives a rather interesting and friendly commentary. Whilst there are some quiet moments, probably as they sit back and enjoy the film, the pair will occasionally burst into life with various quips about the lines, scenery or clever locations to fool us into believing that we're in 1940's Britain.

In the rather interesting fourteen minute Behind the Scenes featurette Christian Slater and Neve Campbell are just a few of the stars who are interviewed. Naturally, everyone praises just about everyone going and how they enjoyed working with such-and-such (although I suspect that some of the American cast members haven't heard of half the British comedians). They all talk about the film and their roles and even Christian Slater admits to Hollywood's outrageous obsession for changing history to suit their films. The featurette is also scattered with a few small clips of behind the scenes footage, bloopers and deleted scenes. All in all it's quite a good featurette with sufficient information to keep you interested throughout.

In the nineteen minute Churchill : The True Story Mockumentary, soldier Lieutenant Ed Baker uncovers the true identity of his father and how his incredible actions during 1939 changed the course of history. Along with plenty of clips from the film, Ed Baker narrates his way through the various "true" events of World War II and even finds himself in downing street interviewing the Prime Minister and other members of the military. It's a great "documentary" and it manages to inject some much needed value into the package with some additional footage clearly made for the featurette.

With an optional commentary from director Peter Richardson, the five minutes of deleted or extended scenes are of little value, although the scene with Eva Braun ringing into a radio talk programme is reasonably amusing. Richardson does his best to explain the reasoning behind the cuts, and to be honest it makes a change to find a disc with a commentary rather than having to decide for yourself. However, it's the usual problem with pacing that is the prime reason for the majority of the cuts, whilst some of the jokes didn't play too well.

Again, with an optional commentary from the director, the two minute Alternative Beginning and Ending contains the original idea of opening and closing the film with a group of Hollywood producers re-writing history. Fortunately, these scenes were dropped and the film is much better without them. Still, it's nice to see them included here. Things are rounded off with a minutes worth of unfunny Outtakes whilst the Theatrical Trailer and four TV Spots are included for good measure. All in all, it's a good selection of extras which fans of the film are bound to enjoy.

With the likes of the forthcoming war film Battle of Britain and the existing titles U571 and Saving Private Ryan, Hollywood has the nasty habit of rewriting our history and removing Britain from the heroic exploits of World War II. Ask some of today's youngsters brought up on a diet of Hollywood block busters and you'll be hard pressed to find anyone who realises that our grandfathers also made the ultimate sacrifice in the defence of our freedom. So, what better way than to fight back with our great, and rarely understood outside of these shores, sense of humour.

And in the case of Churchill : The Hollywood Years the comedy fight back is in the form of some cutting satire which pokes fun at not only Hollywood but also at the British. Trouble is, it helps if the satire is any good and it ultimately struggles along with very few laughs, and most of those come from the minor roles. It simply tries too hard to be a modern Monty Python and, rather unfortunately, it fails. I can't even think of a scene where either Christian Slater or Neve Campbell made me laugh. It really is a missed opportunity to poke some much needed fun at those history altering Hollywood moguls.

Still, I actually remember the Comic Strip Presents when it was originally broadcast on Channel Four and it was wacky and weird then. Perhaps this comedy is simply too surreal for me to appreciate. Never the less, there are some plus points. Christian Slater is obviously game for a laugh (or the pay cheque at least - which to be fair can't have been that much) whilst Harry Enfield is certainly worth his laughs as a clueless King George V who gives a possible indication of what the bumbling Charles will be like when he finally reaches the throne. Even the inimitable Jon Culshaw and his impression of Tony Blair is worth a look in.

In what is an extremely average film, which I'm sure will completely sink without a trace outside the UK, Pathé have certainly done a good job in presenting the film in a more attractive manner. The menu system is clever whilst there's a good selection of extras to keep the faithful fans happy. Whilst it may not attract a massive fan base, or a large amount of sales, it may at least be worth a rental for those curious types.

  • Audio Commentary with Christian Slayer and Peter Richardson
  • Making of Featurette
  • Churchill : The True Story Mockumentary
  • Deleted Scenes
  • Outtakes
  • Alternative Beginning and Ending with Commentary by Peter Richardson
  • Theatrical Trailer and TV Spots
The Rum Diary artwork

The Rum Diary

DVD
27/03/2013
American journalist Paul Kemp takes on a freelance job in Puerto Rico for a local newspaper during the 1960s and struggles to find a balance between island culture and the expatriates who live there.
The Butterfly Effect artwork
Family Guy Presents Blue ... artwork
The Last King of Scotland artwork
Contagion artwork

Contagion

BD
04/03/2012
Team America artwork

Team America

DVD
16/05/2005
A Discovery of Witches S2 artwork

A Discovery of Witches S2

DVDBDTVBoxset
04/02/2021
After being forced back into the world of magic, Diana Bishop, a historian and reluctant witch, returns in A Discovery of Witches: Season 2, released on DVD and Blu-ray 12th April 2021 from Spirit ...
A Killer Next Door artwork

A Killer Next Door

DVD
11/02/2021
Gattaca artwork

Gattaca

UHD
14/02/2021
Deutschland '89 artwork

Deutschland '89

DVDTV
23/02/2021
Nemesis artwork

Nemesis

DVD
16/02/2021
The Ten Commandments artwork

Escape Plan

Features04/12/2020

The world's foremost expert in prison security is trapped in a brutal black-ops fortress housing the world's most dangerous criminals in Escape Plan, a high-octane action-thriller driven by the explosive star power of Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Peep Show S4

Review21/08/2019

Mark and Jez are a couple of twenty-something roommates who have personalities that are completely opposite to each other - and with absolutely nothing in common. Series four sees the mayhem continue with Mark desperately trying to get out of marrying Sophie.

NOS4A2 S1 and 2

News26/02/2021

Star Trek's Zachary Quinto stars as the evil Charlie Manx in NOS4A2, a different kind of vampire story based on the New York Times best-selling novel, released on DVD 8th March 2021, courtesy of Acorn Media International
"Some people can't believe in themselves until someone else believes in them first."
Good Will Hunting (1997)

An American Pickle

DVD07/12/2020500

Tremors

UHDBD14/12/2020321

Cats and Dogs 3

DVDDIGITAL08/02/2021299

The Good Fight S4

DVDTV05/04/2021261

The Good Fight S4

DVDTV05/04/2021261

It's A Sin

DVDBDTV22/02/2021152

Riviera S3

DVDBDTV11/01/2021125

Radioactive

DVDNOTES24/04/2020158

Fantasy Island

DVDBDNOTES14/02/202093

The Broken Hearts Gallery

DVDDIGITALNOTES18/01/202140

Possessor

DVDBDNOTES08/02/202135

Racing Stripes

DVD21/06/20053040

Austin Powers

DVD01/12/20071461

The Simpsons S16

DVDTV05/12/2013978

The Burnt Orange Heresy

DIGITAL
02/02/2021

Archenemy

DVD
05/02/2021

Lovecraft Country S1

DVDBDTV
25/01/2021

The Host

BD
23/02/2021
Get a free daily news update. DVD365.net works with the Amazon Alexa flash briefing skill