DVD Head to Head Review

 

Details

Thirteenth Floor (R1) Vs (R2)

1 Hour 40 Minutes

 

 

Cast

Douglas Hall Craig Bierko
Hannon Fuller Armin Mueller-Stahl
Whitney D'Onofrio Vincent D'Onofrio
Jane Fuller Gretchen Mol
Detective Larry McBain Dennis Haysbert

Synopsis

On the Thirteenth Floor of a corporate tower block, Douglas Hall and a colleague are working on a new form of virtual reality...A version of Los Angeles circa 1937.

Film

Computer scientist Hannon Fuller has discovered something very important. He's going to tell his discovery to his college Douglas Hall, but fearing for his safety, he leaves a letter in a VR computer simulation of the 30's but that same night he is murdered and Douglas is suspected.

When Douglas awakes the following day he discovers a blood stained shirt in his bathroom. Trouble is, he doesn't know where it came from and can't remember what he was doing the night before. When the murdered victims daughter, the beautiful Jane Fuller, arrives from Paris things start to become even less clear and he ventures into Fuller's virtual reality world in order to discover the truth, which, when unraveled is more shocking than he, or anyone, could ever have imagined.

This is one stylish film however, with an excellent quality picture to go with it. Some of the outside scenes in the region one edition are breathtaking with bright colours pushing your TV and DVD player to its limits, and dark night scenes making your player work just as hard. However, the region two edition appears to be quite grainy with a low bit-rate and suffers from too much contrast. This is especially evident during the scenes set in the 30's.

Paul thought that the sound quality on the region one edition, although good, didn't use the 5.1 channels to good effect, but since the film is heavy on dialogue, this was probably not a surprise. However, the region two edition uses the channels well with plenty of ambient music and effects in the surround channels. There's even plenty of LFE's throughout, but they were a little over used. Another difference of opinion perhaps? 

The 'before and after' SFX section on the disc is worth a mention. It shows the various skylines and landscapes before the computer got to work on them and turned them in to 1930's LA. And they say that the camera never lies!

We really enjoyed this film and it certainly scores a parallel with "The Matrix" and will stand up to repeat watches, especially when the gorgeous Fuller (Mol) is on screen. Whether you like it depends on one thing...Do you like "The Outer Limits" or "The Twilight Zone", if you do, you'll like this film...If not...Well, its not a bad reference disc, and the extras are excellent along with a very pretty menu system on the region one disc. 

Extras

Region One Edition Region Two Edition
  • Production Notes
  • Theatrical Trailer
  • Bonus Trailers
  • DVD-ROM and Web Link
  • Director and Production Designer Audio Commentary
  • Before And After SFX Gallery
  • Conceptual Art Gallery
  • Music Video By "The Cardigans" (Erase And Rewind)
  • Talent Files
  • Director and Production Designer Audio Commentary
  • Before and After SFX Gallery
  • Conceptual Art Gallery
  • Filmographies
  • Music Video by "The Cardigans" (Erase And Rewind)
  • Theatrical Trailer
  • Multiple Language Subtitles

Conclusion

Again, the region two edition misses out on the huge number of extras which graces the region one edition. The region one edition also offers a full screen version for the anti-widescreen types. However, what extras remain on the region two edition are still worth the price of the disc. Perhaps the addition of 13 different language subtitles meant the loss of some of these extras, but with another region two disc loosing the animated menus, plus the poorer picture quality, if your player is multi-region then choose the region one edition.

Reviewed by: Paul (R1) and Simon (R2)

DD DD DD
Buy this DVD from Amazon.com Buy this DVD from Amazon.ca Buy this DVD from Amazon.co.uk