Review View All

Affliate advertisement
Star Wars : Episode One Review


Buy the DVD from Amazon.co.uk
DVD

"A conflict is brewing between the powerful Trade Federation and the peaceful planet of Naboo and two Jedi's have been dispatched to mediate between the two sides."
Disc format
DVD
Picture
2.35:1
Sound
Dolby Digital EX (5.1)
Running time
2 Hours 6 Minutes
Region(s)
1
Rating
blank
Genre
Review date
30th November 1999
Recommended
No
Cast
Liam Neeson
Ewan McGregor
Natalie Portman
Jake Lloyd
Ian McDiarmid
Pernilla August
Ahmed Best
Ray Park
Character
Qui-Gon Jinn
Obi-Wan Kenobi
Queen Amidala/Padmé Naberrie
Anakin Skywalker
Senator Palpatine
Shmi Skywalker
Jar Jar Binks
Darth Maul
Story
With the conflict brewing between the powerful Trade Federation and the peaceful planet of Naboo, the Federation is blockading the planet. Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn, and his apprentice Obi-Wan Kenobi, travel to Naboo in an attempt to confront the Federation and prevent war breaking out. However, the negotiations don't go to plan and they head for the planet to warn the Queen of the impending invasion and the more sinister reasons behind it.
The Jedi manage to evacuate the Queen and her court, but their spacecraft suffers damage during the escape and they must find somewhere to land and make repairs to the ship. They travel to the desert planet of Tatooine where they meet a young slave boy called Anakin Skywalker. Qui-Gon senses that there is something special about this boy and is sure that fate has led him to him.
Without the necessary funds to repair the ship they are forced to enter a pod-race with the young Anakin racing for them. Anakin is a smart child and has built his own ship to enter the race. It is a race he needs to win as Qui-Gon has bet the Naboo spacecraft with a local junk yard dealer who has the spare part he needs to repair the ship.
With the Naboo rescued from the planet the Trade Federation is unable to force her to sign an agreement making the invasion legal. The sinister leader behind the blockade and invasion plot decides to send one of his Jedi warriors, Darth Maul, to hunt down the ship and force the queen to sign the agreement.
Picture and Sound
The picture is unbelievably sharp with some fantastic colour tones and details and no doubt down to the fact that the film was filmed and stored digitally. There is not a picture blemish or hint of pixelisation in sight. However, although it is good, it is still not perfect. The fact that it is so good has caused a number of problems. With the heavy dependency on computer animation it can be all too easy to spot the computers work. Although the space battles and cities scenes are flawless, it is the droid invasion and subsequent invasion of Naboo that is the disappointment. At times you could almost be watching a cut scene on a computer game it is that obvious.
There can also be some hideous amounts of outlining around the characters, again, this becomes more apparent when there is some sort of computer generated animation in the background, and it most likely caused by the actors being shot against a blue screen.
If the picture is somewhat disappointing then the sound makes up for it in a big way. Whereas the 25th anniversary Laserdisc reissues were rather disappointing in the sound department this THX soundtrack is breathtaking and truly demonstration material. Naturally, it is the pod race and space battles where the soundtrack truly comes into its own with a plentiful supply of surround effects and deep rumblings from the sub-woofer. Even people listening on a humble stereo hi-fi or television will be hard pushed not to be impressed.
There was one strange thing that I noticed with the subtitling and I'm not sure whether it was just down to my DVD player. Whenever someone spoke in an alien tongue there were no subtitles on the screen and I didn't have a clue what they were talking about. I was certain that subtitles had been present at the cinema so I checked the available subtitles and eventually found another English subtitle track with the alien translations on them. A deliberate ploy? I'm not sure.
Overall
It was both a pity and a credit to the public that Lucas relented and released the film onto DVD. He was not planning on releasing it until the other episodes had been released and no doubt it would have been in an expensive box-set. The internet was awash with petitions and sites criticising Lucas, but the cynics amongst you may suspect that he was finally pressurised into releasing the film in order to boost the coffers at Fox and the pay the way for the subsequent episodes.
Let's not dwell on the fact that this film has not plot what-so-ever and it leaves wondering just what the hell was going on for the past two hours - it all ends so quick. It is almost as if there was so much information Lucas wanted to fit into the film that he hurriedly, and excitedly, created the film without much thought for the humble viewer.
And lets face it, the pod race was created purely for the computer console market and we can argue until the end of time about Jar Jar Binks. Never-the-less the film is visually stunning and sounds fantastic. Its success was purely on the hype and expectations alone. Let's just hope that the next episode is better than this one as the viewing public may be a little more suspicious next time around. Still, a disc sure the grace all DVD collections the world over.
Extras Overview
Disc One
  • Commentary by George Lucas, Rick McCallum, Ben Burtt, Rob Coleman, John Knoll, Dennis Muren and Scott Squires
Disc Two
  • Seven Deleted Scenes Completed for DVD
  • Deleted Scenes Documentary
  • All-new Hour Long Documentary Created from Over 600 Hours of Footage
  • Multi-angle Storyboard-to-Animatic-to-Film Segments
  • Five Featurettes Explore The Phantom Menace Storyline, Design, Costumes, Visual Effects and Fight Scenes
  • Award Winning Twelve Part Web Documentary Series that Chronicles the Production of Episode I
  • "Duel of the Fates" Music Video Featuring John Williams
  • Never-before-seen Production Photo Gallery with Special Caption Feature
  • Theatrical Posters and Print Campaigns from Around the World
  • Theatrical Teaser and Launch Trailers, plus Seven TV Spots
  • "Star Wars: Starfighter - The Making of a Game" Featurette from Lucas Arts
  • DVD-ROM Weblink to Exclusive Star Wars Contents
Reviewed By
Simon
Disqus
Discuss the Star Wars : Episode One DVD review here. Why not join in the discussion and help keep these pages self sufficient within the community?
Latest Reviews View All
The Rum Diary : American journalist Paul Kemp takes on a freelance job in Puerto Rico for a local newspaper during the 1960s and struggles to find a balance between island culture and the expatriates who live there.
0 comments 0 reactions
  • The Revenant : When Bart, a soldier serving in Iraq, wakes up the morning after his own funeral, he does what every normal person does when climbing out of a coffin - head off to see his best friend and carry on lif...
    0 comments 0 reactions
  • Shameless : Series 10 : The unthinkable has happened - the Department of Work and Pensions have finally caught up with job dodger Frank. Faced with losing his benefits, he finds himself in a nightmare fantasy on death row, h...
    0 comments 0 reactions
  • Paranormal Activity 4 : It has been five years since the disappearance of Katie and Hunter, and a suburban family start to witness strange events in their neighbourhood when a woman and a mysterious sickly looking child move...
    0 comments 0 reactions
Most Popular View All
Racing Stripes : A baby Zebra is adopted by farmer's daughter and grows up thinking that it's a racehorse with a burning desire to race in the Kentucky Open.
19 hits 0 comments 0 reactions
  • Shameless : Series 10 : The unthinkable has happened - the Department of Work and Pensions have finally caught up with job dodger Frank. Faced with losing his benefits, he finds himself in a nightmare fantasy on death row, h...
    17 hits 0 comments 0 reactions
  • Max Payne : The Harder Cut : Max Payne moves from the video game arena to the big screen as a rogue cop out for revenge for the brutal murder of his wife and family. Get ready for beautiful women, dark allies and plenty of gunfir...
    11 hits 0 comments 0 reactions
  • The Rum Diary : American journalist Paul Kemp takes on a freelance job in Puerto Rico for a local newspaper during the 1960s and struggles to find a balance between island culture and the expatriates who live there.
    7 hits 0 comments 0 reactions